WYPR 88.1 FM Baltimore WYPF 88.1 FM Frederick WYPO 106.9 FM Ocean City

Justice Department files lawsuit against Dali owner, claims negligence led to Key Bridge collapse

Your browser doesn’t support HTML5 audio

Miguel Luna’s uniform on display. A CASA spokesperson said his wife Carmen, wanted people to see the shrapnel from his welding.
Wambui Kamau

The federal Department of Justice has filed a civil lawsuit against the owners of the Dali, the ship that struck the Francis Scott Key Bridge in March, leading to its collapse and the deaths of six construction workers.

During a call with reporters on Wednesday, Deputy Associate Attorney General Benjamin Mizer announced that the lawsuit seeks over $100 million in damages. The amount reflects the costs incurred by the federal government to clean up the accident and reopen the Fort McHenry channel and the Port of Baltimore. Mizer emphasized that the financial responsibility for the damage should rest with the ship's owners, not taxpayers.

Breakdown of cleanup, recovery, and reopening costs according to DOJ:

  • $74 million - U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
  • $22 million - U.S. Coast Guard
  • $3.5 million - U.S. Department of Labor
  • $2 million - U.S. Navy
  • $850 thousand - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)
  • $800 thousand - U.S. Maritime Administration

The lawsuit alleges that ship owner Grace Ocean Private Limited and its operator Synergy Marine Private Limited, were aware of vibration problems on the vessel that could lead to power failures. The Dali experienced multiple power outages shortly after leaving the port on the morning of March 26.

“Out of mismanagement, negligence, and at times a desire to cut costs, they configured the ship’s electrical and mechanical systems in a way that prevented those systems from being able to quickly restore steering and propulsion after a power outage,” Mizer stated.

The DOJ suit is seeking unspecified punitive damages too, which is a rare thing for the department to do according to Mizer. He told reporters that’s in hopes of sending a message to shipping companies to prevent future accidents like this from occurring.

In April, the Singapore-based company filed a petition to limit its liability to about $44 million under the Limitation of Liability Act of 1851. Grace Ocean also asked the U.S District Court to impose September 24th as the deadline for any more lawsuits to be filed. Three families of the six construction workers who died in the incident announced their own lawsuits against the Dali's owners on Tuesday. Those families spoke at a press conference hosted by CASA, an immigrant rights advocacy group. During their announcement, CASA’s Executive Director Gustavo Torres criticized the ship owner’s actions beyond its court filing.

“They hired a federal lobbying firm working behind closed doors to rewrite the very law designated to protect the vulnerable to try to reduce the liability and responsibility,” he said. “And now the ship is back on the waters, sailing as if nothing happened.”

The DOJ’s lawsuit is also a response to the Dali’s legal action seeking exoneration or limitation of liability.

WYPR’S Matt Bush contributed to this story.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Wambui Kamau is a General Assignment Reporter for WYPR. @WkThee
Related Content
  1. Families of Key Bridge collapse victims to file lawsuit against shipping company
  2. Maryland Transportation Authority taps Kiewit to design Key Bridge rebuild
  3. Baltimore considering bill to make it easier for city to recoup damages from Key Bridge crash
  4. Lawmakers introduce bill that could hold company responsible for Baltimore’s Key Bridge collapse
  5. Survivor of Key Bridge collapse: ‘I looked at the bridge and it was no longer there’
  6. NTSB says electrical breaker failure caused blackout on ship that hit Key Bridge
  7. Key Bridge cleanup cost $100 million, but more costs still to come
  8. Johns Hopkins starting nationwide study on bridge safety after Key Bridge collapse in Baltimore
  9. First company files suit against owns of the Dali, which brought down Key Bridge in Baltimore
  10. Poorly regulated foreign vessels could cause a repeat of Baltimore bridge collapse in other U.S. ports
  11. Baltimore takes first steps to sue owners of Dali
  12. Families of two killed during Key Bridge collapse and survivor hire lawyers
  13. Baltimore hires law firms to sue those responsible for FSK Bridge collision
  14. FBI opens criminal probe into Key Bridge collapse, raids Dali